<a id="recipes-ipccwg1ar5ch9"></a>

# IPCC AR5 Chapter 9 (selected figures)

## Overview

The goal of this recipe is to collect diagnostics to reproduce Chapter 9 of AR5,
so that the plots can be readily reproduced and compared to previous CMIP
versions. In this way we can next time start with what was available in the
previous round and can focus on developing more innovative methods of analysis
rather than constantly having to “re-invent the wheel”.

#### NOTE
Please note that most recipes have been modified to include only models that are
(still) readily available via ESGF. Plots produced may therefore look different
than the original figures from IPCC AR5.

The plots are produced collecting the diagnostics from individual recipes. The
following figures from Flato et al. (2013) can currently be reproduced:

> * Figure 9.2 a,b,c: Annual-mean surface air temperature for the period
>   1980-2005. a) multi-model mean, b) bias as the difference between the
>   CMIP5 multi-model mean and the climatology from ERA-Interim
>   (Dee et al., 2011), c) mean absolute model error with respect to the
>   climatology from ERA-Interim.
> * Figure 9.3: Seasonality (December-January-February minus June-July-August)
>   of surface (2 m) air temperature (°C) for the period 1980-2005.
>   (a) Multi-model mean for the historical experiment. (b) Multi-model mean
>   of absolute seasonality. (c) Difference between the multi-model mean
>   and the ERA-Interim reanalysis seasonality. (d) Difference between the
>   multi-model mean and the ERA-Interim absolute seasonality.
> * Figure 9.4: Annual-mean precipitation rate (mm day-1) for the period
>   1980-2005. a) multi-model mean, b) bias as the difference between the
>   CMIP5 multi-model mean and the climatology from the Global Precipitation
>   Climatology Project (Adler et al., 2003), c) multi-model mean absolute
>   error with respect to observations, and d) multi-model mean error
>   relative to the multi-model mean precipitation itself.
> * Figure 9.5: Climatological (1985-2005) annual-mean cloud radiative
>   effects in Wm-2 for the CMIP5 models against CERES EBAF (2001-2011) in
>   Wm-2. Top row shows the shortwave effect; middle row the longwave effect,
>   and bottom row the net effect. Multi-model-mean biases against CERES
>   EBAF 2.6 are shown on the left, whereas the right panels show zonal
>   averages from CERES EBAF 2.6 (black), the individual CMIP5 models (thin
>   gray lines), and the multi-model mean (thick red line).
> * Figure 9.6: Centered pattern correlations between models and observations
>   for the annual mean climatology over the period 1980–1999. Results are
>   shown for individual CMIP3 (black) and CMIP5 (blue) models as thin
>   dashes, along with the corresponding ensemble average (thick dash) and
>   median (open circle). The four variables shown are surface air
>   temperature (TAS), top of the atmosphere (TOA) outgoing longwave
>   radiation (RLUT), precipitation (PR) and TOA shortwave cloud radiative
>   effect (SW CRE). The correlations between the reference and alternate
>   observations are also shown (solid green circles).
> * Figure 9.8: Observed and simulated time series of the anomalies in annual
>   and global mean surface temperature. All anomalies are differences from
>   the 1961-1990 time-mean of each individual time series. The reference
>   period 1961-1990 is indicated by yellow shading; vertical dashed grey
>   lines represent times of major volcanic eruptions. Single simulations
>   for CMIP5 models (thin lines); multi-model mean (thick red line);
>   different observations (thick black lines). Dataset pre-processing like
>   described in Jones et al., 2013.
> * Figure 9.14: Sea surface temperature plots for zonal mean error, equatorial
>   (5 deg north to 5 deg south) mean error, and multi model mean for zonal error
>   and equatorial mean.
> * Figure 9.24: Time series of (a) Arctic and (b) Antarctic sea ice extent;
>   trend distributions of (c) September Arctic and (d) February Antarctic
>   sea ice extent.
> * Figure 9.26: Ensemble-mean global ocean carbon uptake (a) and global land
>   carbon uptake (b) in the CMIP5 ESMs for the historical period 1900–2005.
>   For comparison, the observation-based estimates provided by the Global
>   Carbon Project (GCP) are also shown (thick black line). The confidence
>   limits on the ensemble mean are derived by assuming that the CMIP5 models
>   are drawn from a t-distribution. The grey areas show the range of annual mean
>   fluxes simulated across the model ensemble. This figure includes results
>   from all CMIP5 models that reported land CO2 fluxes, ocean CO2 fluxes, or
>   both (Anav et al., 2013).
> * Figure 9.27: Simulation of global mean (a) atmosphere–ocean CO2 fluxes
>   (“fgCO2”) and (b) net atmosphere–land CO2 fluxes (“NBP”), by ESMs for the
>   period 1986–2005. For comparison, the observation-based estimates
>   provided by Global Carbon Project (GCP) and the Japanese Meteorological
>   Agency (JMA) atmospheric inversion are also shown. The error bars for the
>   ESMs and observations represent interannual variability in the fluxes,
>   calculated as the standard deviation of the annual means over the period
>   1986–2005.
> * Figure 9.38: Seasonal cycle for the surface temperature or precipitation
>   over land within defined regions multi-model mean and difference to
>   reference dataset or absolute annual cycle can be chosen.
> * Figure 9.39: Seasonal bias box and whiskers plot
>   for surface temperature or precipitation within
>   SREX (IPCC Special Report on Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and
>   Disasters to Advance Climate Change Adaptation) regions.
> * Figure 9.40: Seasonal bias box and whiskers plot for surface
>   temperature or precipitation within defined polar and ocean regions.
> * Figure 9.41b: Comparison between observations and models for variable
>   values within defined regions.
> * Figure 9.42a: Equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) against the global
>   mean surface air temperature, both for the period 1961-1990 and for the
>   pre-industrial control runs.
> * Figure 9.42b: Transient climate response (TCR) against equilibrium climate
>   sensitivity (ECS).
> * Figure 9.45a: Scatterplot of springtime snow-albedo effect values in climate
>   change vs. springtime d(alpha<sub>s</sub>)/d(T<sub>s</sub>) values in the seasonal
>   cycle in transient climate change experiments (Hall and Qu, 2006).

## Available recipes and diagnostics

Recipes are stored in esmvaltool/recipes/recipe_ipccwg1ar5ch9

> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figures_92_95.yml: Figures 9.2, 9.3, 9.4, 9.5
> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figure_96.yml: Figure 9.6
> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figure_98.yml: Figure 9.8
> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figure_914.yml: Figure 9.14
> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figure_924.yml: Figure 9.24
> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figures_926_927.yml: Figures 9.26 and 9.27
> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figure_942.yml: Figure 9.42
> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figure_945a.yml: Figure 9.45a
> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figures_938_941_cmip3.yml: Figures 9.38, 9.39, 9.40, and 9.41
> * recipe_flato13ipcc_figures_938_941_cmip6.yml: Figures 9.38, 9.39, 9.40, and 9.41 CMIP6 instead of CMIP3
> * recipe_weigel21gmd_figures_13_16.yml: ESMValTool paper version (Weigel et al., 2021) of Figures 9.38, 9.39, 9.40, and 9.41, only CMIP5

Diagnostics are stored in esmvaltool/diag_scripts/

> * carbon_cycle/main.ncl: See [here](recipe_anav13jclim.html.md#recipes-anav13jclim).
> * climate_metrics/ecs.py: See [here](recipe_ecs.html.md#ecs-py).
> * clouds/clouds_bias.ncl: global maps of the multi-model mean and the multi-model
>   mean bias (Fig. 9.2, 9.4)
> * clouds/clouds_ipcc.ncl: global maps of multi-model mean minus observations + zonal
>   averages of individual models, multi-model mean and observations (Fig. 9.5)
> * ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_3.ncl: multi-model mean seasonality of near-surface
>   temperature (Fig. 9.3)
> * ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_6.ncl: calculating pattern correlations of annual mean
>   climatologies for one variable (Fig 9.6 preprocessing)
> * ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_6_collect.ncl: collecting pattern correlation for each
>   variable and plotting correlation plot (Fig 9.6)
> * ipcc_ar5/tsline.ncl: time series of the global mean (anomaly) (Fig. 9.8)
> * ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_14.py: Zonally averaged and equatorial SST (Fig. 9.14)
> * seaice/seaice_tsline.ncl: Time series of sea ice extent (Fig. 9.24a/b)
> * seaice/seaice_trends.ncl: Trend distributions of sea ice extent (Fig 9.24c/d)
> * regional_downscaling/Figure9_38.ncl (Fig 9.38a (variable tas) and Fig 9.38b (variable pr))
> * regional_downscaling/Figure9_39.ncl (Fig 9.39a/c/e (variable tas) and Fig 9.39b/d/f (variable pr))
> * regional_downscaling/Figure9_40.ncl (Fig 9.40a/c/e (variable tas) and Fig 9.40b/d/f (variable pr))
> * regional_downscaling/Figure9_41.ncl (Fig 9.41b)
> * ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_42a.py: ECS vs. surface air temperature (Fig. 9.42a)
> * ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_42b.py: TCR vs. ECS (Fig. 9.42b)
> * emergent_constraints/snowalbedo.ncl: snow-albedo effect (Fig. 9.45a)

## User settings in recipe

1. Script carbon_cycle/main.ncl

   See [here](recipe_anav13jclim.html.md#recipes-anav13jclim).
2. Script climate_metrics/ecs.py

   See [here](recipe_ecs.html.md#ecs-py).
3. Script clouds/clouds_bias.ncl

   *Required settings (scripts)*

   none

   *Optional settings (scripts)*
   * plot_abs_diff: additionally also plot absolute differences (true, false)
   * plot_rel_diff: additionally also plot relative differences (true, false)
   * projection: map projection, e.g., Mollweide, Mercator
   * timemean: time averaging, i.e. “seasonalclim” (DJF, MAM, JJA, SON),
     “annualclim” (annual mean)
   * Required settings (variables)\*
   * reference_dataset: name of reference dataset

   *Optional settings (variables)*
   * long_name: description of variable

   *Color tables*
   * variable “tas”: diag_scripts/shared/plot/rgb/ipcc-tas.rgb,
     diag_scripts/shared/plot/rgb/ipcc-tas-delta.rgb
   * variable “pr-mmday”: diag_scripts/shared/plots/rgb/ipcc-precip.rgb,
     diag_scripts/shared/plot/rgb/ipcc-precip-delta.rgb
4. Script clouds/clouds_ipcc.ncl

   *Required settings (scripts)*

   none

   *Optional settings (scripts)*
   * explicit_cn_levels: contour levels
   * mask_ts_sea_ice: true = mask T < 272 K as sea ice (only for variable “ts”);
     false = no additional grid cells masked for variable “ts”
   * projection: map projection, e.g., Mollweide, Mercator
   * styleset: style set for zonal mean plot (“CMIP5”, “DEFAULT”)
   * timemean: time averaging, i.e. “seasonalclim” (DJF, MAM, JJA, SON),
     “annualclim” (annual mean)
   * valid_fraction: used for creating sea ice mask (mask_ts_sea_ice = true):
     fraction of valid time steps required to mask grid cell as valid data

   *Required settings (variables)*
   * reference_dataset:  name of reference data set

   *Optional settings (variables)*
   * long_name: description of variable
   * units: variable units

   *Color tables*
   * variables “pr”, “pr-mmday”: diag_scripts/shared/plot/rgb/ipcc-precip-delta.rgb
5. Script ipcc_ar5/tsline.ncl

   *Required settings for script*
   * styleset: as in diag_scripts/shared/plot/style.ncl functions

   *Optional settings for script*
   * time_avg: type of time average (currently only “yearly” and “monthly” are
     available).
   * ts_anomaly: calculates anomalies with respect to the defined period; for
     each grid point by removing the mean for the given calendar month
     (requiring at least 50% of the data to be non-missing)
   * ref_start: start year of reference period for anomalies
   * ref_end: end year of reference period for anomalies
   * ref_value: if true, right panel with mean values is attached
   * ref_mask: if true, model fields will be masked by reference fields
   * region: name of domain
   * plot_units: variable unit for plotting
   * y-min: set min of y-axis
   * y-max: set max of y-axis
   * mean_nh_sh: if true, calculate first NH and SH mean
   * volcanoes: if true, lines of main volcanic eruptions will be added
   * run_ave: if not equal 0 than calculate running mean over this number of
     years
   * header: if true, region name as header

   *Required settings for variables*

   none

   *Optional settings for variables*
   * reference_dataset: reference dataset; REQUIRED when calculating
     anomalies

   *Color tables*
   * e.g. diag_scripts/shared/plot/styles/cmip5.style
6. Script ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_3.ncl

   *Required settings for script*

   none

   *Optional settings for script*
   * projection: map projection, e.g., Mollweide, Mercator (default = Robinson)

   *Required settings for variables*
   * reference_dataset: name of reference observation

   *Optional settings for variables*
   * map_diff_levels: explicit contour levels for plotting
7. Script ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_6.ncl

   *Required settings for variables*
   * reference_dataset: name of reference observation

   *Optional settings for variables*
   * alternative_dataset: name of alternative observations
8. Script ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_6_collect.ncl

   *Required settings for script*

   none

   *Optional settings for script*
   * diag_order: List of diagnostic names in the order variables
     should appear on x-axis
9. Script seaice/seaice_trends.ncl

   *Required settings (scripts)*
   * month: selected month (1, 2, …, 12) or annual mean (“A”)
   * region: region to be analyzed ( “Arctic” or “Antarctic”)

   *Optional settings (scripts)*
   * fill_pole_hole: fill observational hole at North pole, Default: False

   *Optional settings (variables)*
   * ref_model: array of references plotted as vertical lines
10. Script seaice/seaice_tsline.ncl

    *Required settings (scripts)*
    * region: Arctic, Antarctic
    * month: annual mean (A), or month number (3 = March, for Antarctic; 9 = September for Arctic)

    *Optional settings (scripts)*
    * styleset: for plot_type cycle only (cmip5, cmip6, default)
    * multi_model_mean: plot multi-model mean and standard deviation (default: False)
    * EMs_in_lg: create a legend label for individual ensemble members (default: False)
    * fill_pole_hole: fill polar hole (typically in satellite data) with sic = 1 (default: False)
11. Script regional_downscaling/Figure9.38.ncl

    *Required settings for script*

    none

    *Optional settings (scripts)*
    * styleset: for plot_type cycle (e.g. CMIP5, CMIP6), default “CMIP5”
    * fig938_region_label: Labels for regions, which should be included
      ([“WNA”, “ENA”, “CAM”, “TSA”, “SSA”, “EUM”, “NAF”,”CAF”, “SAF”, “NAS”,
      “CAS”, “EAS”, “SAS”, “SEA”, “AUS”]), default “WNA”
    * fig938_project_MMM: projects to average, default “CMIP5”
    * fig938_experiment_MMM: experiments to average, default “historical”
    * fig938_mip_MMM: mip to average, default “Amon”
    * fig938_names_MMM: names in legend  i.e. ([“CMIP5”,”CMIP3”]), default fig938_project_MMM
    * fig938_colors_MMM: Color for multi-model mean (e.g. [“red”]), default “red”
    * If set fig938_mip_MMM, fig938_experiment_MMM, fig938_project_MMM, fig938_names_MMM, and fig938_colors_MMM must
      have the same number of elements
    * fig938_refModel: Reference data set for differences default “ERA-Interim”
    * fig938_MMM: Plot multi-model mean (true/false), default “true”
    * fig938_YMin: minimum Y Axis
    * fig938_YMax: maximum Y Axis
    * fig938_diff: Difference to reference data (true) or absolute annual cycle (false), default “true”
12. Script regional_downscaling/Figure9.39.ncl

    *Required settings (scripts)*
    * reference_dataset: reference dataset name (set of variables)

    *Optional settings (scripts)*
    * styleset: for plot_type cycle (e.g. CMIP5, CMIP6), default “CMIP5”
    * fig939_season: seasons i.e. ([“DJF”,”JJA”,”ANN”]), default “DJF”
    * fig939_region_label: Labels for regions, which should be included
      ([“ALAs”,”CGIs”,”WNAs”,”CNAs”,”ENAs”,”CAMs”,”AMZs”,”NEBs”,”WSAs”,”SSAs”,
      “NEUs”,”CEUs”,”MEDs”,”SAHs”,”WAFs”,”EAFs”,”SAFs”,”NASs”,”WASs”,”CASs”,
      “TIBs”,”EASs”,”SASs”,”SEAs”,”NAUs”,”SAUs”]), default “ALAs”
    * fig939_project_MMM: projects to average, default “CMIP5”
    * fig939_experiment_MMM: experiments to average, default “historical”
    * fig939_mip_MMM: mip to average, default “Amon”
    * fig939_MMM: Plot multi-model mean (true/false)
    * fig939_names_MMM: names in legend  i.e. ([“CMIP5”,”CMIP3”])
    * fig939_YMin: minimum Y Axis
    * fig939_YMax: maximum Y Axis
    * fig939_vert_line_pos: i.e. ([6,10,13,17,24,26])
    * fig939_vert_line_label: labels of vertical lines, i.e. ([“North America”,
      “South America”,”Europe”,”Africa”,”Asia”,”Australia”])
    * fig939_mode: True= cumulative mode
13. Script regional_downscaling/Figure9.40.ncl

    *Required settings (scripts)*
    * reference_dataset: reference dataset name (set of variables)

    *Optional settings (scripts)*
    * styleset: for plot_type cycle (e.g. CMIP5, CMIP6), default “CMIP5”
    * fig940_season: seasons i.e. ([“DJF”,”JJA”,”ANN”]), default “DJF”
    * fig940_region_label: Labels for regions, which should be included
      ([“Arctic_land”,”Arctic_sea”,”Antarctic_land”,”Antarctic_sea”,
      “Caribbean”,”WesternIndianOcean”,”NorthernIndianOcean”,
      “NorthernTropicalPacific”,”EquatorialTropicalPacific”,
      “SouthernTropicalPacific”,”World_land”,”World_sea”,”World”]),
      default “Arctic_land”
    * fig940_project_MMM: projects to average, default “CMIP5”
    * fig940_experiment_MMM: experiments to average, default “historical”
    * fig940_mip_MMM: mip to average, default “Amon”
    * fig940_MMM: Plot multi-model mean (true/false)
    * fig940_names_MMM: names in legend  i.e. ([“CMIP5”,”CMIP3”])
    * fig940_YMin: minimum Y Axis
    * fig940_YMax: maximum Y Axis
    * fig940_vert_line_pos: i.e. ([6,10,13,17,24,26])
    * fig940_vert_line_label: labels of vertical lines, i.e. ([“North America”,
      “South America”,”Europe”,”Africa”,”Asia”,”Australia”])
    * fig940_mode: True= cumulative mode
14. Script regional_downscaling/Figure9.41.ncl

    *Required settings (scripts)*
    * reference_dataset: reference dataset name (set of variables)

    *Optional settings (scripts)*
    * styleset: for plot_type cycle (e.g. CMIP5, CMIP6), default “CMIP5”
    * fig941_region_label: Labels for regions, which should be included
      ([“ALAs”,”CGIs”,”WNAs”,”CNAs”,”ENAs”,”CAMs”,”AMZs”,”NEBs”,”WSAs”,”SSAs”,
      “NEUs”,”CEUs”,”MEDs”,”SAHs”,”WAFs”,”EAFs”,”SAFs”,”NASs”,”WASs”,”CASs”,
      “TIBs”,”EASs”,”SASs”,”SEAs”,”NAUs”,”SAUs”]), default “MEDs”
15. Script ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_42a.py

    *Required settings for script*

    none

    *Optional settings for script*
    * axes_functions: [`dict`](https://docs.python.org/3/builtins/stdtypes.html#dict) containing methods executed for the plot’s
      [`matplotlib.axes.Axes`](https://matplotlib.org/stable/api/_as_gen/matplotlib.axes.Axes.html#matplotlib.axes.Axes) object.
    * dataset_style: name of the style file (located in
      `esmvaltool.diag_scripts.shared.plot.styles_python`).
    * matplotlib_style: name of the matplotlib style file (located in
      `esmvaltool.diag_scripts.shared.plot.styles_python.matplotlib`).
    * save: [`dict`](https://docs.python.org/3/builtins/stdtypes.html#dict) containing keyword arguments for the function
      [`matplotlib.pyplot.savefig()`](https://matplotlib.org/stable/api/_as_gen/matplotlib.pyplot.savefig.html#matplotlib.pyplot.savefig).
    * seaborn_settings: Options for [`seaborn.set_theme()`](https://seaborn.pydata.org/generated/seaborn.set_theme.html#seaborn.set_theme) (affects all
      plots).

<a id="ch09-fig09-42b-py"></a>
1. Script ipcc_ar5/ch09_fig09_42b.py

   *Required settings for script*

   none

   *Optional settings for script*
   * dataset_style: Dataset style file (located in
     `esmvaltool.diag_scripts.shared.plot.styles_python`). The entry
     `marker` is ignored when `marker_file` is given.
   * log_x: Apply logarithm to X axis (ECS).
   * log_y: Apply logarithm to Y axis (TCR).
   * marker_column: Name of the column to look up markers in `marker_file`.
   * marker_file: CSV file with markers (can also be integers). Must have the
     columns `dataset` and `marker` (or the column specified by
     `marker_column`).  If a relative path is given, assumes that this is a
     pattern to search for ancestor files.
   * savefig_kwargs: Keyword arguments for [`matplotlib.pyplot.savefig()`](https://matplotlib.org/stable/api/_as_gen/matplotlib.pyplot.savefig.html#matplotlib.pyplot.savefig).
   * seaborn_settings: Options for [`seaborn.set_theme()`](https://seaborn.pydata.org/generated/seaborn.set_theme.html#seaborn.set_theme) (affects all
     plots).
   * x_lim: Plot limits for X axis (ECS).
   * y_lim: Plot limits for Y axis (TCR).
2. Script emergent_constraints/snowalbedo.ncl

   *Required settings for script*
   * exp_presentday: name of present-day experiment (e.g. “historical”)
   * exp_future: name of climate change experiment (e.g. “rcp45”)

   *Optional settings for script*
   * diagminmax: observational uncertainty (min and max)
   * legend_outside: create extra file with legend (true, false)
   * styleset: e.g. “CMIP5” (if not set, this diagnostic will create its own
     color table and symbols for plotting)
   * suffix: string to be added to output filenames
   * xmax: upper limit of x-axis (default = automatic)
   * xmin: lower limit of x-axis (default = automatic)
   * ymax: upper limit of y-axis (default = automatic)
   * ymin: lower limit of y-axis (default = automatic)

   *Required settings for variables*
   * ref_model: name of reference data set

   *Optional settings for variables*

   none

## Variables

* areacello (fx, longitude latitude)
* fgco2 (ocean, monthly mean, longitude latitude time)
* nbp (ocean, monthly mean, longitude latitude time)
* pr (atmos, monthly mean, longitude latitude time)
* rlut, rlutcs (atmos, monthly mean, longitude latitude time)
* rsdt (atmos, monthly mean, longitude latitude time)
* rsuscs, rsdscs (atmos, monthly mean, longitude latitude time)
* rsut, rsutcs (atmos, monthly mean, longitude latitude time)
* sic (ocean-ice, monthly mean, longitude latitude time)
* tas (atmos, monthly mean, longitude latitude time)
* tos (ocean, monthly mean, longitude, latitude, time)

## Observations and reformat scripts

*Note: (1) obs4MIPs data can be used directly without any preprocessing;
(2) see headers of reformat scripts for non-obs4MIPs data for download
instructions.*

* CERES-EBAF (rlut, rlutcs, rsut, rsutcs - obs4MIPs)
* ERA-Interim (tas, ta, ua, va, zg, hus - esmvaltool/cmorizers/data/formatters/datasets/era-interim.py)
* GCP2018 (fgco2, nbp - esmvaltool/cmorizers/data/formatters/datasets/gcp2018.py)
* GPCP-SG (pr - obs4MIPs)
* JMA-TRANSCOM (fgco2, nbp - esmvaltool/cmorizers/data/formatters/datasets/jma_transcom.py)
* HadCRUT4 (tas - esmvaltool/cmorizers/data/formatters/datasets/hadcrut4.ncl)
* HadISST (sic, tos - esmvaltool/cmorizers/data/formatters/datasets/hadisst.ncl)
* ISCCP-FH (rsuscs, rsdscs, rsdt - esmvaltool/cmorizers/data/formatters/datasets/isccp_fh.ncl)

## References

* Flato, G., J. Marotzke, B. Abiodun, P. Braconnot, S.C. Chou, W. Collins, P.
  Cox, F. Driouech, S. Emori, V. Eyring, C. Forest, P. Gleckler, E. Guilyardi,
  C. Jakob, V. Kattsov, C. Reason and M. Rummukainen, 2013: Evaluation of
  Climate Models. In: Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis.
  Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the
  Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Stocker, T.F., D. Qin, G.-K.
  Plattner, M. Tignor, S.K. Allen, J. Boschung, A. Nauels, Y. Xia, V. Bex and
  P.M. Midgley (eds.)]. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom
  and New York, NY, USA.
* Hall, A., and X. Qu, 2006: Using the current seasonal cycle to constrain
  snow albedo feedback in future climate change, Geophys. Res. Lett., 33,
  L03502, doi:10.1029/2005GL025127.
* Jones et al., 2013: Attribution of observed historical near-surface temperature
  variations to anthropogenic and natural causes using CMIP5 simulations. Journal
  of Geophysical Research: Atmosphere, 118, 4001-4024, doi:10.1002/jgrd.50239.
* Seneviratne, S. I., Nicholls, N., Easterling, D., Goodess, C. M., Kanae, S.,
  Kossin, J., Luo, Y., Marengo, J., McInnes, K., Rahimi, M., Reichstein, M.,
  Sorteberg, A., Vera, C., and Zhang, X., 2012:
  Changes in climate extremes and their impacts on the naturalphysical
  environment. , in: Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to
  Advance Climate Change Adaptation.  A Special Report of Working Groups I and
  II of the Intergovernmental Panel on ClimateChange (IPCC), edited by:
  Field, C. B., Barros, V., Stocker, T. F., Qin, D., Dokken, D. J.,
  Ebi, K. L., Mastrandrea, M. D., Mach, K. J., Plattner, G.-K., Allen, S. K.,
  Tignor, M., and Midgley, P. M., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK,
  and New York, NY, USA, 109-230.
* Weigel, K., Bock, L., Gier, B. K., Lauer, A., Righi, M., Schlund, M., Adeniyi, K.,
  Andela, B., Arnone, E., Berg, P., Caron, L.-P., Cionni, I., Corti, S., Drost, N.,
  Hunter, A., Lledó, L., Mohr, C. W., Paçal, A., Pérez-Zanón, N., Predoi, V., Sandstad,
  M., Sillmann, J., Sterl, A., Vegas-Regidor, J., von Hardenberg, J., and Eyring, V.:
  Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool) v2.0 - diagnostics for extreme events,
  regional and impact evaluation, and analysis of Earth system models in CMIP,
  Geosci. Model Dev., 14, 3159-3184, [https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-14-3159-2021](https://doi.org/10.5194/gmd-14-3159-2021), 2021.

## Example plots

![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-2.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-3.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-4.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-5.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-6.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-8.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-14.png)![image](recipes/figures/seaice/trend_sic_extend_Arctic_September_histogram.png)![image](recipes/figures/seaice/extent_sic_Arctic_September_1960-2005.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-26.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-27.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-38.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-38-pr.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-38_regions.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-39.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-39-pr.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-39_regions.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-40.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-40-pr.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-40_regions.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-41b.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-42a.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-42b.png)![image](recipes/figures/ipccwg1ar5ch9/fig-9-45a.png)
